e-rhizome 2019, 1(2):113-131 | DOI: 10.5507/rh.2019.006

The Historian (of Religions) as Detective

Luther H. Martin
University of Vermont
161 St. Paul Street, #304; Burlington, VT, United States
luther.martin@uvm.edu

Since my graduate school days, I have been interested in the philosophy of history, especially in historiographical methods. And, I have long been intrigued by the proposition that such methods are also represented by those of detectives (e.g., Robin Winks 1969), particularly, the detectives of fiction. However, it was only with my retirement that I began extensively to read detective novels and, given my historical field of Graeco-Roman religions, I was especially interested in those of Lindsey Davis about Marcus Didius Falco, a "private informer," that are set in the first-century Roman Empire. What might be the historiographical value of such novels, if any? This question was intensified by the recent argument of philosopher Alex Rosenberg (2018) that historical narratives are no more trustworthy than fiction. Consequently, I reflect, in this article, on the historical value both of historical narratives and of historical fiction.

Keywords: detectives, historical-detective stories, historiography, historical narratives, Lindsey Davis, literary stories, Theory of Mind, Alex Rosenberg, Lisa Zunshine.

Accepted: March 4, 2020; Published: December 30, 2019  Show citation

ACS AIP APA ASA Harvard Chicago Chicago Notes IEEE ISO690 MLA NLM Turabian Vancouver
Martin, L.H. (2019). The Historian (of Religions) as Detective. e-rhizome, 1(2), 113-131. doi: 10.5507/rh.2019.006
Share...
Download citation
  • BibTeX (.bib)
  • Bookends (.ris)
  • EasyBib (.ris)
  • EndNote (.enw)
  • EndNote 8 (.xml)
  • ISI WoS (.isi)
  • Medlars (.medlars)
  • Mendeley (.ris)
  • MODS (.xml)
  • Papers (.ris)
  • RefWorks (.txt)
  • RefManager (.ris)
  • RIS (.ris)
  • MS Word (.xml)
  • Zotero (.ris)
    • Open full article

    References

    1. Badcock, Christopher. "The Genius of Detective Fiction," 2010. Accessed 2/27/2019. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-imprinted-brain/201001/the-genius-detective-fiction.
    2. Becker, Carl L. "Everyman His Own Historian." American Historical Review 37 (1932): 221-236; reprinted in The Historian as Detective: Essays on Evidence, edited by R. W. Winks. New York: Harper and Row, 1969, 5-23. Go to original source...
    3. Beemgee. "Why is Crime Fiction so Popular? Accessed 4/27/2019. https://www.beemgee.com/blog/crime-fiction/ (blog).
    4. Blin, Arnaud. War and Religion: Europe and the Mediterranean from the First through the Twenty-First Centuries. Oakland: University of California Press, 2019.Burke, James Lee. Creole Belle. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2012. Go to original source...
    5. Carlyle, Thomas. On Heroes, Hero-Worship and the Heroic in History. London: James Fraser, [1841] 1993.
    6. Carroll, Maureen. 2006. Spirits of the Dead: Roman Funerary Commemoration in Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Go to original source...
    7. Clauss, Manfred. The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and His Mysteries, translated by R. Gordon. London: Routledge, 2001.Collingwood, Robin G. The Idea of History. New York: Oxford University Press, [1946] 1956.
    8. Darwin, Charles. The Origin of Species. New York: Signet Classic, [1859] 2003.Davis, Lindsey. The Iron Hand of Mars. London: Hutchinson, 1992.
    9. Davis, Lindsey. Three Hands in the Fountain. New York: Mysterious Press, 1996.Davis, Lindsey. Two for the Lions. New York: Mysterious Press, 1998.
    10. Davis, Lindsey. One Virgin Too Many. New York: Mysterious Press, 1999.
    11. Davis, Lindsey. Falco on the Loose [Three of Davis' novels bound as one: Last Act in Palmyra (1994), Time to Depart (1995), A Dying Light in Corduba (1996)]. London: Arrow Books, 2001a.
    12. Davis, Lindsey. Ode to a Banker, New York: Mysterious Press Books, 2001b.Davis, Lindsey. "Authors' Introduction," The Silver Pigs, New York: Minotaur Books [1989], 2011. Go to original source...
    13. Dawkins, Richard. Unweaving the Rainbow: Science, Delusion, and the Appetite for Wonder. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998.Devery, Christopher. "Criminal Profiling and Criminal Investigation." Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 26.4 (2010): 393-409. Go to original source...
    14. Dickerson, Mary Jane. "The Convergence of History and Poetry: Part I-Toward a Poetics of the Past," in Vermont Poets and Their Craft, edited by Neil Sheppart and Tamra J. Higgens, Brattleboro, Vermont: Green Writer's Press, 2019, 83-92.Gaddis, John Lewis. The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002.
    15. Graf, Fritz. "ritual," The Oxford Classical Dictionary. Fourth ed. edited by Simon Hornblower, Anthony Spawforth., and Esther Eidenow. 1280b-1282a. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.Gopnik, Alison. "Theory of Mind," in The MIT Encyclopedia of the Cognitive Sciences, edited by Robert A. Wilson and Frank C. Keil,. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press, 1999, 838-840.
    16. Hannah, Sophie. "It's No Mystery that Crime is the Biggest-selling Genre in Books." The Guardian: Books Blog, Crime Fiction, 12 April 2018. Accessed 6/20/2019. https://theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2018/apr/12/mystery-crime-fiction-bestselling-book-genre-sophie-hannahHegel, G. W. F. The Philosophy of History, translated by J. Sibree. New York: Dover, [1861] 1956.
    17. Hersch, Karen K. The Roman Wedding: Ritual and Meaning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.Hobsbawm, Eric. "The New Threat to History." The New York Review of Books, 16 December 1993, 62-64.
    18. Hock, Ronald F. "Response to Rodney Stark's 'Jewish Conversion and the Rise of Christianity'," paper presented at the Social History of Early Christianity Group of the Society of Biblical Literature, Atlanta, 1986, unpublished, cited by Stark 1996: 21-22.Jensen, Anthony K. "Nietzsche and the Truth of History," in The New Cambridge Companion to Nietzsche, edited by Tom Stern, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019, 249-272. Go to original source...
    19. Kismaric, Carole and Marvin Heiferman. The Mysterious Case of Nancy Drew & The Hardy Boys. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1998.LaCapra, Dominick. History and Criticism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1985.
    20. Martin, Luther H. "Rituals, Modes, Memory and Historiography: The Cognitive Promise of Harvey Whitehouse". Journal of Ritual Studies 16. 2 (2002): 30-33.Martin, Luther H. "The Deep History of Religious Ritual," in Secular Theory, Deep History: Scientific Studies of Religion, Collected Essays of Luther H. Martin, Berlin: de Gruyter, 2014, 254-271 Go to original source...
    21. Martin, Luther H. The Mind of Mithraists: Historical and Cognitive Studies of the Roman Cult of Mithras. London: Bloomsbury, 2015.Martin, Luther H. "Consilience: Science, the Humanities, and the Study of Religion." Culture and Research, forthcoming article.
    22. Martin, Luther H. "Seeing the Mithraic Tauroctony," in The Mysteries of Mithras and other Mystic Cults in the Roman World, edited by P. Johnston, A. Mastrocinque and László Takács, Acta Antiqua Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó, forthcoming book.Martin, Luther H. "Is There a Future for a Scientific Study of Religion?" Presentation to a conference on Step Back and Look Beyond: Studying Religion after 2020, Bochum, Germany, March 11-13, 2020.McCutcheon, Russell T., Willi Braun, Burton Mack, and Randall Collins, "A Symposium on Rodney Stark's The Rise of Christianity. Religious Studies Review 25 (1999): 127-139.
    23. Meeks, Wayne A. The First Urban Christians: The Social World of the Apostle Paul. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1983.Momigliano, Arnaldo. "The Introduction of the Teaching of History as an Academic Subject and Its Implications." Minerva 21.1 (1983): 1-15.
    24. Mynott, Jeremy. Birds in the Ancient World Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.
    25. New World Encyclopedia: "Poe." Accessed 5/2/2019 http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Edgar_Allan_PoeNitecki, Matthew H. and Doris V. Nitecki, eds. History and Evolution. Albany: SUNY, 1992.
    26. Otaley, Keith. "Fiction: Simulation of Social Worlds." Trends in Cognitive Science, 20.8 (2016): 618-629.Pachis, Panayotis and Donald Wiebe. "Preface," Chasing Down Religion: In the Sights of History and the Cognitive Sciences. Essays in Honor of Luther H. Martin, edited by P. Pachis and D. Wiebe, Thessaloniki: Barbounakis Publications, 2010, XLVII-XLIX; rpt. by Equinox: Sheffield, UK, 2010, XXXVI-XXXVIII. Go to original source...
    27. Popkin Richard H. "Scepticism and the Study of History," in Physics, Logic, and History, edited by W. Yourgrau and A. D. Breck, Boston: Springer, 1970, 209-230.Price, Simon R. F. Rituals and Power: The Roman Imperial Cult in Asia Minor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984.
    28. "Publishing ... and Other Forms of Insanity," November 16, 2017. Accessed 5/2/2019. https://publishedtodeath.blogspot.com/2017/11/what-are-most-popular-literary-genres.htmlRosenberg, Alex. How History Gets Things Wrong: The Neuroscience of Our Addiction to Stories. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press, 2018.
    29. Rutledge, Steven. H. Imperial Inquisitions: Prosecutors and Informants from Tiberius to Domitian. London: Routledge, 2001.Scheidel, Walter ed. The Science of Roman History: Biology, Climate, and the Future of the Past. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2018. Go to original source...
    30. Shaw, David Gary, ed. Agency after Postmodernism. Theme Issue of History and Theory 40.4 (2001).Shaw, David Gary and Philip Pomper, eds. The Return of Science: Evolutionary Ideas and History. Theme Issue of History and Theory 38.4 (1999).
    31. Shryock, Andrew and Daniel Lord Smail. Deep History: The Architecture of Past and Present. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2011. Go to original source...
    32. Slingerland, Edward, Ryan Nichols, Kristoffer Neilbo, Carson Logan. 2017. "The Distant Reading of Religious Texts: A "Big Data" Approach to Mind-Body Concepts in Early China." Journal of the American Academy of Religion 85. 4: 985-1016. Go to original source...
    33. Smail, Daniel Lord. On Deep History and the Brain. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2008.Silverman, Kenneth. Edgar A. Poe: Mournful and Never-ending Remembrance. New York: Harper Perennial, 1991.
    34. Simmel, Georg. The Problems of the Philosophy of History: An Epistemological Essay, trans. of 2nd ed., by Guy Oakes. New York: Free Press, [1905] 1977.Snyder, Graydon F. Ante Pacem: Archaeological Evidence of Church Life Before Constantine. Macon GA: Mercer University Press., [1985] 2003.
    35. Sokal, Alan and Jean Bricmont. Fashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectuals' Abuse of Science. New York: Picador, 1998.Sperber, Dan, ed. Metarepresentations: A Multidisciplinary Perspective. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000.
    36. Spencer, Herbert. The Study of Sociology. New York: Appleton,1896.Stark, Rodney. The Rise of Christianity: A Sociologist Reconsiders History. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 1996.
    37. Thomas, Ronald R. Detective Fiction and the Rise of Forensic Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999.White, Hayden. Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-century Europe. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1973.
    38. White, Hayden. "Interpretation in History." New Literary History 4.2 (1973): 281-314.Whitehouse, Harvey. Inside the Cult: Religious Innovation and Transmission in Papua New Guinea. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995. Go to original source...
    39. Whitehouse, Harvey. Arguments and Icons: Divergent Modes of Religiosity. Oxford University Press, 2000.Williams, Wirt. Review of James Lee Burke, Half of Paradise, "On the Tracks to Doom: HALF OF PARADISE" (Boston: Houghton Mifflin). New York Times Book Review, 14 March 1965: BR46Winks, Robin W. The Historian as Detective: Essays on Evidence. New York: Harper & Row, 1969.
    40. Yoffe, Emily. "Innocence is Irrelevant." The Atlantic, 320.2 (September 2017): 66-74.Zak, Paul J. "Why Inspiring Stories Make Us React: The Neuroscience of Narrative." Cerebrum: The Dana Forum on Brain Science 2015: 2.
    41. Zunshine, Lisa. Why We Read Fiction: Theory of Mind and the Novel. Columbus: The Ohio State University Press, 2006.

    This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0), which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original publication is properly cited. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.


    Return to the content